MLB The Show 24: All Legends Listed

As with every new release, eager eyes have been waiting for the vaunted legends trailer for MLB The Show 24. News has been slow to trickle out and we had to wait until a couple days before early access for the new legends. That said, we don’t know every legend as of yet but know a general number and we’ll list all the legends we know of as of today.

A brief trailer was released on Monday highlighting new legends coming to the game. We haven’t seen a full confirmed list yet, but we’ll update this post in the future once we have a complete list of legends.

Returning Legends

With the scarce amount of trailers and news, we’ve only seen a handful of confirmed legends that are returning. The returning legends we’ve spotted so far include:

• Roy Halladay
• Mike Mussina
• Randy Johnson
• Pedro Martinez
• Greg Maddux
• Tom Glavine
• Mariano Rivera
• Billy Wagner
• Brian Wilson
• Robb Nen
• Trevor Hoffman
• John Smoltz
• Derek Jeter
• Mark McGwire
• David Ortiz
• Larry Walker
• Ryan Braun
• Joe Mauer
• Chase Utley
• Ivan Rodriguez
• Frank Thomas
• Chipper Jones
• Vladimir Guerrero
• Sammy Sosa
• Ian Kinsler
• David Wright
• Alex Gordon
• Matt Holliday
• Tim Raines
• Mike Cameron
• Ryan Ludwick
• Rickey Henderson
• Tony Gwynn
• Ken Griffey Jr.
• Mike Schmidt
• Jim Thome
• Eddie Murray
• Mike Piazza
• Cal Ripken Jr.
• Joe Morgan
• Gary Carter
• Craig Biggio
• George Brett
• Andre Dawson
• Jeff Bagwell
• Orlando Cepeda
• Rod Carew
• Wade Boggs
• Paul Molitor
• Ozzie Smith
• Robin Yount
• Greg Vaughn
• Catfish Hunter
• Bret Saberhagen
• Don Sutton
• Tom Seaver
• Nolan Ryan
• Vida Blue
• Ron Guidry
• John Franco
• Tom Henke
• Bruce Sutter
• Rich Gossage
• Lee Smith
• J.R. Richard
• Fernando Valenzuela
• Jim Palmer
• Dennis Eckersley
• Jackie Robinson
• Mickey Mantle
• Willie Mays
• Hank Aaron
• Lou Gehrig
• Ernie Banks
• Ralph Kiner
• Eddie Mathews
• Johnny Bench
• Buck O’Neil
• Honus Wagner
• Duke Snider
• Roberto Clemente
• Joe Torre
• Harmon Killebrew
• Stan Musial
• Brooks Robinson
• Larry Doby
• Hank Thompson
• Martin Dihigo
• Rube Foster
• Phil Niekro
• Robin Roberts
• Hilton Smith
• Bob Feller
• Juan Marichal
• Whitey Ford
• Babe Ruth
• John Donaldson
• Fergie Jenkins
• Hal Newhouser
• Cy Young
• Satchel Paige
• Bob Gibson
• Warren Spahn
• Rollie Fingers
• Jim Edmonds
• Gary Sheffield
• Bert Blyleven
• Alan Trammell
• Eric Davis
• Todd Helton
• Edgar Martinez
• Willie McCovey
• Luis Gonzalez
• Willie Stargell
• Al Kaline
• Jason Giambi
• Grady Sizemore
• Barry Larkin
• Tony Perez
• Troy Glaus
• Eric Gagne
• Carlos Delgado
• Don Mattingly
• Ryne Sandberg
• Dante Bichette
• Curtis Granderson
• Prince Fielder
• Ryan Howard
• David Justice
• Monte Irvin
• Jimmy Rollins
• Cliff Lee
• Minnie Minoso
• Billy Williams
• Jorge Posada
• Justin Morneau
• Paul Konerko
• Kevin Youkilis
• Rob Dibble
• Torii Hunter
• Steve Finley
• Johnny Damon
• Vinny Castilla
• Matt Cain
• Alfonso Soriano
• Roy Oswalt
• Kerry Wood
• A.J. Burnett
• Harold Baines
• Jason Bay
• Joe Nathan
• Michael Young
• Brandon Webb
• Brian Roberts
• Richie Ashburn
• Bill Mazeroski
• Jim Rice
• Lou Brock
• Dontrelle Willis
• Al Leiter
• Adam Dunn
• Mike Napoli
• Mark Prior
• Troy Percival
• Tim Salmon
• Luis Aparicio
• Tony Clark
• Mike Lowell
• Carlos Pena
• Ken Griffey Sr.
• Kyle Seager
• Chili Davis
• Jerry Hairston Jr.
• Raul Ibanez

New Legends

On top of the returning legends, the announced crop of new legends includes:

• Andy Pettitte
• Johan Santana
• Andrew Miller
• Bernie Williams
• Adrian Beltre
• Richie Sexson
• Brian Dozier
• Rich Aurilia
• Tony Tarasco
• John Kruk
• Rafael Palmeiro
• Paul O’Neill
• Josh Gibson
• Buck Leonard
• Toni Stone
• Tony Oliva

It’s probably a safe bet that we’ll see at least a couple unannounced new legends released during the game cycle. SDS typically has a couple pop up every year, so who knows what kind of surprises we might see.

Which legends are you most excited about? Any bold predictions for hidden legends that might be revealed during the year?